Hey, magenta1861917! Sorry to say that I don't have a lot of personal experience with this kind of issue -- I'm definitely a loyal Android-olyte.
That said, our general stance at T-Mo is that Apple will always be the expert on all things Apple, so we'd recommend working with them directly for this kind of equipment issue. It might also be worth calling out that third party repairs often void the warranty on your device; so you may want to bear that in mind when you're considering your options!
Work with Apple directly as the third party places that fix screens don't always use the original type of screen to cut cost. Just work with Apple or file for a exchange if you have insurance.